When Clarins sent over the updated Total Eye LiftI had no idea the formula had been tweaked. It was only four years ago that I wrote a dedicated post during the launch. I enjoyed it then and would never have pegged it for an update. Yet here we are. Did it need to change? I wasn’t expecting it to, and the update honestly threw me a bit. So, where’s the good, the bad, and the brutally honest on this next chapter in Clarins eye care?

What is Total Eye Lift

Little known fact: Clarins is the brand that got me hooked on eye cream when I was twenty-one. I adored their Extra-Firming Eye Contour Cream and would save up for it diligently. Two and a half decades later, I am still a loyalist of the area-specific step. I am a full-on believer in eye creams because of Clarins.

The Positioning

This is the most advanced eye care formula within the Clarins lineup. If you know the brand’s ranges, the red packaging has always been aimed at more mature skin types. As if the word “lift” wasn’t suggestive enough. The formula promises to help with fine lines, puffiness, and overall smoothness for “a visible eye lift in 30 seconds.” That is quite a promise.

What’s in the New Clarins Eye Cream

After going through the previous and current INCI lists side by side, the updated Total Eye Lift is a clear improvement. It keeps all the key de-puffing and firming components but noticeably amplifies soothing, antioxidant, and barrier-supportive ingredients.

What’s Changed

First, let’s confirm what stayed the same. The four main actives are still caffeine, escin, harungana extract, and Acetyl Tetrapeptide-2.

What sets the new version apart is the addition of oat kernel extract for soothing, Hydroxyacetophenone for antioxidant support, Marrubium Vulgare Extract for anti-inflammation, and a trio of algae-derived polysaccharides for hydration and a smoother feel.

Texture and User Experience

The updated formula feels lighter. The original had a whipped creaminess, while the new version behaves more like a lotion. The slip is more elegant, it glides easily, and it absorbs quickly without pilling. Most important, it feels instantly comforting on the delicate skin around the eyes.

Now for the part that makes my blood pressure spike. The packaging is awful. The whole refillable concept feels more gimmicky than helpful, and I am not convinced this is the environmental win it claims to be. After plugging the inner cartridge into the main component, I pumped no less than 34,597 times to prime the bottle. I nearly launched it across the room. I am also mystified how this design will not auto-dispense during transit in a travel bag.

Does It Really Lift

In thirty seconds? No. This is a marketing claim that must be taken with a grain of salt. If it worked as literally as advertised, every Upper East Side plastic surgeon would be out of business. And we all know the influencers used in certain paid ads would say yes to a folding chair if the rate was right. The product is not responsible for their appearance. The only thing lifted is your hope.

What we are actually seeking is the appearance of a lift. If your eye area looks rested, moisturized, and bright, the effect is already there. Clarins makes excellent products and this eye cream is great, but it is not an eye lift in a bottle. Please be reasonable.

A quick word on user reviews.

If you check the Clarins website, the feedback for Total Eye Lift looks overwhelmingly positive, but keep in mind those reviews are not starting from scratch. Clarins bundled all the comments from the previous formula into the listing for the updated version, which makes the overall rating feel a bit skewed. It’s not exactly fair, considering the new formula behaves differently in texture, feel, and performance. If you’re scanning reviews for clues on what to expect, know that many of them refer to an eye cream that no longer exists in that form.

Yay or Nay

Yay. Total Eye Lift is a genuinely solid eye cream and I am enjoying it. I cannot say the same for many of the cleansers Clarins has reformulated recently or for the once-legendary Beauty Flash Balm. If you want more suggestions from the brand, the Double Serum continues to impress, both in formula and delivery system. For body care, the roll-on deodorant and the hand cream remain fantastic.

$95 (15ml) available at clarins.com and sephora.com

Affiliate disclosure: This post contains affiliate links. If you choose to shop through them, I may earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. Thank you for supporting my work and my product testing habit.