If Katseye fans—known as Eyekons—go wild when just one member posts a casual selfie on Instagram, you can imagine the reaction when all five girls grace the June cover of Allure: Total mania. In the beauty-centric photoshoot, Sophia Laforteza, Daniela Avanzini, Lara Raj, Megan Skiendiel, and Yoonchae Jeungn wore polka-dotted lip art and posed alongside huge beauty product props, but it’s Daniela’s bleached brows eliciting the biggest response. Eyekons are divided over whether they love or hate the bold makeup decision from the 21-year-old singer. “Daniela looking stunning with no eyebrows,” one user commented under an Instagram post debuting the cover. “Love a blonde moment,” wrote another fan. Others, however, begged her to “go back to your natural brows.” “I thought she had no eyebrows for a sec. The bleached eyebrows really blend with her skin,” another user wrote.

In true Katseye frenzy, there’s even an entire Reddit thread dedicated to discussing the group’s beauty looks from the shoot. The thread starts with Eyekons fawning over the girls and admiring the “cool” hair and makeup looks, before one fan also inquires about the bleached brows worn by Daniela, Megan, and Lara. Part of the confusion stems from the fact that Daniela’s brows are not bleached in every image. “Is it concealer over them [eyebrows] in the perfume pic? I wonder if that inspired the full bleach?” the fan adds.